1 Ontological Issues for Modelling Aspect
نویسندگان
چکیده
The CASK method (Computer-aided Acquisition of Semantic Knowledge) is being used at CELTA with the SEMANA (SEMantic ANAlyser) software, which was especially designed for this purpose. We use the notation of semantic feature structures as a meta-language for describing the category of aspect in Polish regardless of its pertaining to various levels of expression (morphological, syntactical or lexical). To model the category of aspect we treat types of situations as conditions for two relevant aspect parameters we call analysis of the situation (or internal aspect) and control of the situation (or external aspect). In order to cope both with the lexical diversity of aspectual morphemes (prefixes) and the grammatical (dichotomous and obligatory) character of aspect in Slavic languages, we have proposed to define the perfective aspect as a hypercategory. Our database of Polish aspect was analysed using KDD statistical tools (G. Sauvet 2008, http://celta.parissorbonne.fr/anasem/papers/). We obtained the first preliminary experimentally fixed semantic definitions of the perfective and imperfective values of the category of aspect in a Slavic language. 1. Ontology and Semantics Multi-lingual contrastive studies need to refer to ontologies as tertium comparationis, including those which were especially designed in order to account for linguistic objects (expressions). We claim that this task cannot but be interactive (computer-aided), if we want to avoid the lack of precision and the variability of semantic parameters in traditional linguistic research, especially hazardous in the semantic domain. We define the semantic content of a linguistic expression as a function mapping this expression on ontological concepts. Therefore, to describe the semantic content of aspectual expressions used in utterances we need to specify the ontology to which they refer. A formal cognitive description aims at giving an ontological account of a semantic category by treating its definition in different languages as a finite set of strictly defined feature structures. We aim at giving a two-fold account of semantic categories by: building a general set of ontological abstract structures necessary to interpret aspect in different languages choosing a specific set of semantic feature structures for the described category in each human language, in our case for Polish. To describe aspectual values of verbs in context, we had first to define relevant aspectual semantic attributes and their values (AV). At this stage, linguists must use both 1 Acknowledgment: the research on aspect with the SEMANA software has been conducted at CELTA (Paris-Sorbonne University) since 2005 by Hélène and André Włodarczyk (ontology and semantics of verbal aspect), Georges Sauvet and André Włodarczyk (conception of the SEMANA software), Georges Sauvet (analysis of the aspect database with SEMANA KDD tools). Doctoral and master students also take part in this research.
منابع مشابه
Exploring Proposed Ontological Issues of ARIS with Four Different Types of Modellers
Many organisations in Australia and world-wide are adopting the practice of business process modelling for reasons such as Business Process Management (BPM) and new legislation requirements. As these modelling tasks are often time consuming and expensive, it is important that the tools and techniques that are used can effectively capture the real world systems being modelled. Numerous studies h...
متن کاملDo Process Modelling Techniques Get Better? A Comparative Ontological Analysis of BPMN
Current initiatives in the field of Business Process Management (BPM) strive for the development of a BPM standard notation by pushing the Business Process Modeling Notation (BPMN). However, such a proposed standard notation needs to be carefully examined. Ontological analysis is an established theoretical approach to evaluating modelling techniques. This paper reports on the outcomes of an ont...
متن کاملFormalizing Ontological Commitments
Formalizing the ontological commitment of a logical language means offering a way to specify the intended meaning of its vocabulary by constraining the set of its models, giving explicit information about the intended nature of the modelling primitives and their a priori relationships. We present here a formal definition of ontological commitment which aims to capture the very basic ontological...
متن کاملAn Experimental Evaluation of Property Precedence in Conceptual Modelling
Interest in evaluating conceptual modelling techniques has recently experienced a revival, in part due to widespread adoption of the Unified Modelling Language (UML). In addition, the use of ontology as a framework for evaluating conceptual modelling techniques has gained acceptance. In this paper, we consider implications of applying one aspect of the ontology of Mario Bunge to conceptual mode...
متن کاملOntological modelling of form and function for architectural design
Form, function and the relationship between the two serve a crucial role in design. Within architectural design, key aspects of the anticipated function of buildings, or of spatial environments in general, are supposed to be supported by their structural form, i.e., their shape, layout, or connectivity. Whereas the philosophy of form and function is a well-researched topic, the practical relati...
متن کامل